rows { options { physical_type: PHYSICAL_STREAM_TYPE_QUADS max_name_table_size: 128 max_prefix_table_size: 16 max_datatype_table_size: 16 logical_type: LOGICAL_STREAM_TYPE_DATASETS version: 2 } } rows { prefix { value: "https://w3id.org/np/" } } rows { name { value: "RABpTXhv7R5AdRu8_YNZUgnwOYct5qSzVpmyDuwYoIcgw" } } rows { namespace { name: "this" value { prefix_id: 1 } } } rows { prefix { value: "https://w3id.org/np/RABpTXhv7R5AdRu8_YNZUgnwOYct5qSzVpmyDuwYoIcgw/" } } rows { name { } } rows { namespace { name: "sub" value { prefix_id: 2 } } } rows { prefix { value: "http://www.nanopub.org/nschema#" } } rows { namespace { name: "np" value { prefix_id: 3 name_id: 2 } } } rows { prefix { value: "http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#" } } rows { namespace { name: "rdf" value { prefix_id: 4 name_id: 2 } } } rows { prefix { value: "http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#" } } rows { namespace { name: "prov" value { prefix_id: 5 name_id: 2 } } } rows { prefix { value: "http://purl.org/nanopub/x/" } } rows { namespace { name: "npx" value { prefix_id: 6 name_id: 2 } } } rows { prefix { value: "http://purl.org/dc/terms/" } } rows { namespace { name: "dc" value { prefix_id: 7 name_id: 2 } } } rows { prefix { value: "http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#" } } rows { namespace { name: "xsd" value { prefix_id: 8 name_id: 2 } } } rows { name { value: "hasAssertion" } } rows { name { value: "assertion" } } rows { name { value: "Head" } } rows { quad { s_iri { prefix_id: 1 name_id: 1 } p_iri { prefix_id: 3 name_id: 3 } o_iri { prefix_id: 2 } g_iri { } } } rows { name { value: "hasProvenance" } } rows { name { value: "provenance" } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 3 } o_iri { prefix_id: 2 } } } rows { name { value: "hasPublicationInfo" } } rows { name { value: "pubinfo" } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 3 } o_iri { prefix_id: 2 } } } rows { name { value: "type" } } rows { name { value: "Nanopublication" } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 4 } o_iri { prefix_id: 3 } } } rows { prefix { value: "https://w3id.org/delphi/resource/assessment/" } } rows { name { value: "aristotle-ha04-08--claim-test" } } rows { name { value: "description" } } rows { quad { s_iri { prefix_id: 9 } p_iri { prefix_id: 7 } o_literal { lex: "Each Europe PMC XML was split into sentences. Charonia or triton sentences were scored from PMC5519703: proboscis-bores-shell required a shell perforation named with the proboscis or radula; does-not-bore required the proboscis to penetrate or be inserted into an echinoderm with no shell-boring sentence. Muricid sentences were scored from the other three papers, and a sentence naming Stramonita haemastoma met the muricid rule. The claim passes only if both kinds are proboscis-bores-shell. Both kinds were scored and the trumpet-shell was not, so the conjunction refutes. The denominator is the two named kinds." } g_iri { prefix_id: 2 name_id: 4 } } } rows { prefix { value: "https://w3id.org/delphi/ontology/" } } rows { name { value: "Assessment" } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 4 name_id: 10 } o_iri { prefix_id: 10 name_id: 14 } } } rows { prefix { value: "http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#" } } rows { name { value: "comment" } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 11 } o_literal { lex: "Measured: 0.5 fraction of the two named kinds (purple murex, trumpet-shell) scored proboscis-bores-shell (n = 2, kinds scored: 2 of 2). Interpretation: The sentence is about two testaceans, the purple murex and the ceryx (trumpet-shell), and it says their proboscis bores through the shells of the shellfish they eat. Purple murex is scored as Muricidae. Trumpet-shell is scored as Charonia, the giant triton, not as every tonnoidean. Boring a hole in a shell is the observation. Eating an echinoderm by pushing the proboscis into its body is not boring a shell. The accessory boring organ, when a paper places it in the foot, is not the proboscis." } } } rows { name { value: "label" } } rows { quad { p_iri { } o_literal { lex: "Claim test of aristotle-ha04-08: refutes, confidence 0.73" } } } rows { name { value: "seeAlso" } } rows { prefix { value: "https://github.com/fractastical/delphisci/blob/bf2af6ee0a84e23ffa6414ad7a0a50a8c276506e/test-data/claim-tests/aristotle-biology/aristotle-ha04-08/" } } rows { name { value: "result.json" } } rows { quad { p_iri { } o_iri { prefix_id: 12 } } } rows { name { value: "wasAttributedTo" } } rows { prefix { value: "https://w3id.org/delphi/resource/agent/" } } rows { name { value: "delphisci-claim-tester-grok-4-7" } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 5 } o_iri { prefix_id: 13 } } } rows { name { value: "admissibleDatasets" } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 10 } o_literal { lex: "Checksummed papers that report feeding or shell-drilling observations for Muricidae and for Charonia. A diet list that does not say whether a shell was perforated is not enough. FishBase is fishes and is not admissible." } } } rows { name { value: "assessmentType" } } rows { quad { p_iri { } o_literal { lex: "claim-test/0.1.0" } } } rows { name { value: "dataKind" } } rows { quad { p_iri { } o_literal { lex: "biological" } } } rows { name { value: "disconfirmingObservation" } } rows { quad { p_iri { } o_literal { lex: "Either kind is described as not perforating shells, or as perforating them with an organ other than the proboscis." } } } rows { name { value: "evidenceAgainst" } } rows { quad { p_iri { } o_literal { lex: "Mondal et al. 2021 count drillholes and say some could be muricid, but they expect mostly naticid holes and do not name a proboscis. That paper is not the muricid sentence that was scored." } } } rows { quad { o_literal { lex: "The Cassidae sentence in the triton paper, about boring a sea-urchin body wall with a radula and proboscis, is a different family and was not scored as Charonia." } } } rows { quad { o_literal { lex: "The purple murex is scored from Stramonita haemastoma, a muricid, not from a species named Murex. The sentence says the accessory boring organ and the radula drill the bivalve shell and the proboscis is inserted into the hole. That meets the pre-registered muricid rule because the radula takes part. It is one species standing for the kind Aristotle names." } } } rows { quad { o_literal { lex: "The trumpet-shell is Charonia. PMC5519703 records the proboscis penetrating a crown-of-thorns starfish. No sentence in that paper says Charonia bores a mollusc shell. One of two kinds fails, so the conjunction refutes." } } } rows { quad { o_literal { lex: "n is the two named kinds, not a count of individual snails." } } } rows { name { value: "expectedObservation" } } rows { quad { p_iri { } o_literal { lex: "A checksummed account of Muricidae and a checksummed account of Charonia each say that the animal perforates a prey shell and that the proboscis takes part." } } } rows { name { value: "failCriterion" } } rows { quad { p_iri { } o_literal { lex: "Refutes if both kinds are scored and at least one is not proboscis-bores-shell. A kind that the same papers describe as feeding by inserting the proboscis into soft tissue without perforating a shell is does-not-bore. A kind described as drilling shells with an accessory boring organ or the foot, and not with the proboscis, is bores-not-proboscis. A kind described as drilling shells with the organ unnamed is bores-organ-unnamed. All three are not proboscis-bores-shell. Inconclusive, reason underpowered, if exactly one kind is scored. Inconclusive, reason data-unavailable, if neither paper states a feeding or drilling act for either kind. Inconclusive, reason not-operationalizable, if the papers name the animals and do not say whether a shell is perforated." } } } rows { name { value: "hasConfidence" } } rows { datatype { value: "http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#double" } } rows { quad { p_iri { } o_literal { lex: "0.73" datatype: 1 } } } rows { name { value: "hasEvidence" } } rows { prefix { value: "https://w3id.org/delphi/resource/evidence/" } } rows { name { value: "aristotle-ha04-08--claim-test--dataset-1" } } rows { quad { p_iri { } o_iri { prefix_id: 14 } } } rows { name { value: "aristotle-ha04-08--claim-test--dataset-2" } } rows { quad { o_iri { } } } rows { name { value: "aristotle-ha04-08--claim-test--dataset-3" } } rows { quad { o_iri { } } } rows { name { value: "aristotle-ha04-08--claim-test--dataset-4" } } rows { quad { o_iri { } } } rows { name { value: "hasVerdict" } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 10 } o_literal { lex: "refutes" } } } rows { name { value: "hypothesis" } } rows { quad { p_iri { } o_literal { lex: "Both the purple murex (Muricidae) and the trumpet-shell (Charonia) perforate the shells of shelled prey with the proboscis." } } } rows { name { value: "inferenceMethod" } } rows { quad { p_iri { } o_literal { lex: "Two kinds, scored independently as proboscis-bores-shell or not. The claim passes only if both are. It refutes if both are scored and either is not. One scored kind is underpowered." } } } rows { name { value: "passCriterion" } } rows { quad { p_iri { } o_literal { lex: "Each named kind is scored from a checksummed paper, separately. A kind is proboscis-bores-shell only if a sentence names that kind (Muricidae, muricid, murex or Stramonita for the purple murex; Charonia or triton for the trumpet-shell) together with a shell perforation (bore, drill or borehole) and names the proboscis or the radula it carries as taking part. The claim passes only if both kinds are proboscis-bores-shell. The denominator is the two named kinds." } } } rows { name { value: "preregistered" } } rows { datatype { value: "http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#boolean" } } rows { quad { p_iri { } o_literal { lex: "false" datatype: 2 } } } rows { prefix { value: "https://w3id.org/delphi/resource/claim/" } } rows { name { value: "aristotle-ha04-08" } } rows { name { value: "hasAssessment" } } rows { quad { s_iri { prefix_id: 15 } p_iri { prefix_id: 10 } o_iri { prefix_id: 9 name_id: 12 } } } rows { quad { s_iri { prefix_id: 14 name_id: 30 } p_iri { prefix_id: 7 name_id: 13 } o_literal { lex: "feeding of Charonia: proboscis penetration of a starfish, not a shell" } } } rows { name { value: "license" } } rows { quad { p_iri { name_id: 41 } o_literal { lex: "http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" } } } rows { name { value: "EvidenceItem" } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 4 name_id: 10 } o_iri { prefix_id: 10 name_id: 42 } } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 11 name_id: 16 } o_literal { lex: "Dataset: Bose et al. 2017, giant triton salivary gland and feeding on crown-of-thorns starfish" } } } rows { name { value: "atLocation" } } rows { prefix { value: "https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC5519703/" } } rows { name { value: "fullTextXML" } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 5 name_id: 43 } o_iri { prefix_id: 16 } } } rows { name { value: "wasDerivedFrom" } } rows { prefix { id: 6 value: "https://doi.org/10.1038/" } } rows { name { value: "s41598-017-05974-x" } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 5 } o_iri { prefix_id: 6 } } } rows { name { value: "hasChecksum" } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 10 } o_literal { lex: "sha256:3bc7131fa48bc580d571f664b68e942e6c8ae75db4c85f88676e9e47b5196730" } } } rows { quad { s_iri { prefix_id: 14 name_id: 31 } p_iri { prefix_id: 7 name_id: 13 } o_literal { lex: "drillhole census; fetched because it names muricid drilling. It did not supply the muricid sentence that was scored" } } } rows { quad { p_iri { name_id: 41 } o_literal { lex: "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" } } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 4 name_id: 10 } o_iri { prefix_id: 10 name_id: 42 } } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 11 name_id: 16 } o_literal { lex: "Dataset: Mondal et al. 2021, drillholes on the eastern Indian coast" } } } rows { prefix { id: 8 value: "https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC8389373/" } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 5 name_id: 43 } o_iri { prefix_id: 8 } } } rows { prefix { id: 1 value: "https://doi.org/10.1371/" } } rows { name { value: "journal.pone.0256685" } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 5 } o_iri { prefix_id: 1 name_id: 48 } } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 10 name_id: 47 } o_literal { lex: "sha256:eadaf3e2f8a1e5e29c44dc1c7f91c1d1f4c68fed07032007b6b0ca33de52b5c1" } } } rows { quad { s_iri { prefix_id: 14 name_id: 32 } p_iri { prefix_id: 7 name_id: 13 } o_literal { lex: "mentions muricids that drill; the scored muricid sentence is in the Stramonita paper" } } } rows { quad { p_iri { name_id: 41 } o_literal { lex: "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" } } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 4 name_id: 10 } o_iri { prefix_id: 10 name_id: 42 } } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 11 name_id: 16 } o_literal { lex: "Dataset: Fedosov et al. 2025, venom glands of marine predatory snails" } } } rows { prefix { id: 3 value: "https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC12075767/" } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 5 name_id: 43 } o_iri { prefix_id: 3 } } } rows { prefix { id: 2 value: "https://doi.org/10.1093/molbev/" } } rows { name { value: "msaf095" } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 5 } o_iri { prefix_id: 2 name_id: 49 } } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 10 name_id: 47 } o_literal { lex: "sha256:88f81f41a203e38b7e1b2a5575cc5e2a42ed4b1be2fb00315c6b111236166989" } } } rows { quad { s_iri { prefix_id: 14 name_id: 33 } p_iri { prefix_id: 7 name_id: 13 } o_literal { lex: "Stramonita haemastoma (Muricidae) drills bivalve shells with the accessory boring organ and radula, and the proboscis is inserted into the hole" } } } rows { quad { p_iri { name_id: 41 } o_literal { lex: "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/" } } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 4 name_id: 10 } o_iri { prefix_id: 10 name_id: 42 } } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 11 name_id: 16 } o_literal { lex: "Dataset: Ringeval et al. 2026, toxin organs of Monoplex corrugatus and Stramonita haemastoma" } } } rows { prefix { id: 12 value: "https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC12964963/" } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 5 name_id: 43 } o_iri { prefix_id: 12 } } } rows { prefix { value: "https://doi.org/10.1186/" } } rows { name { value: "s12864-026-12592-3" } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 5 } o_iri { prefix_id: 13 name_id: 50 } } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 10 name_id: 47 } o_literal { lex: "sha256:5b501e093690b183f8fce74bd997beedf746be54e5e7e5f2de2ede9d8087ea6d" } } } rows { prefix { id: 15 value: "https://w3id.org/delphi/resource/agent/" } } rows { name { value: "SoftwareAgent" } } rows { prefix { id: 9 value: "https://w3id.org/np/RABpTXhv7R5AdRu8_YNZUgnwOYct5qSzVpmyDuwYoIcgw/" } } rows { quad { s_iri { prefix_id: 15 name_id: 20 } p_iri { prefix_id: 4 name_id: 10 } o_iri { prefix_id: 5 name_id: 51 } g_iri { prefix_id: 9 name_id: 7 } } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 11 name_id: 16 } o_literal { lex: "delphisci claim tester (Grok 4.7; cursor/aristotle-life-history-g-a908)" } } } rows { name { value: "actedOnBehalfOf" } } rows { prefix { id: 16 value: "https://orcid.org/" } } rows { name { value: "0009-0007-4948-9192" } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 5 name_id: 52 } o_iri { prefix_id: 16 } } } rows { name { value: "usesModel" } } rows { prefix { id: 6 value: "https://w3id.org/delphi/resource/model/" } } rows { name { value: "grok-4-7" } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 10 } o_iri { prefix_id: 6 } } } rows { name { value: "identifier" } } rows { quad { s_iri { name_id: 55 } p_iri { prefix_id: 7 } o_literal { lex: "Grok 4.7" } } } rows { name { value: "LanguageModel" } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 4 name_id: 10 } o_iri { prefix_id: 10 name_id: 57 } } } rows { quad { s_iri { prefix_id: 9 name_id: 4 } p_iri { prefix_id: 5 name_id: 19 } o_iri { prefix_id: 15 } } } rows { prefix { id: 8 value: "https://github.com/fractastical/delphisci/blob/bf2af6ee0a84e23ffa6414ad7a0a50a8c276506e/test-data/claim-tests/aristotle-biology/aristotle-ha04-08/" } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 5 name_id: 45 } o_iri { prefix_id: 8 name_id: 18 } } } rows { name { value: "wasGeneratedBy" } } rows { name { value: "test" } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 5 name_id: 58 } o_iri { prefix_id: 9 } } } rows { name { value: "plan" } } rows { name { value: "hadPlan" } } rows { prefix { id: 1 value: "https://github.com/fractastical/delphisci/blob/bf2af6ee0a84e23ffa6414ad7a0a50a8c276506e/test-data/claim-tests/" } } rows { name { value: "README.md" } } rows { quad { s_iri { } p_iri { prefix_id: 5 } o_iri { prefix_id: 1 } } } rows { name { value: "Activity" } } rows { quad { s_iri { prefix_id: 9 name_id: 59 } p_iri { prefix_id: 4 name_id: 10 } o_iri { prefix_id: 5 name_id: 63 } } } rows { name { value: "qualifiedAssociation" } } rows { quad { p_iri { } o_iri { prefix_id: 9 name_id: 60 } } } rows { name { value: "wasAssociatedWith" } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 5 name_id: 65 } o_iri { prefix_id: 15 name_id: 20 } } } rows { prefix { id: 3 value: "https://w3id.org/np/" } } rows { name { value: "created" } } rows { datatype { value: "http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#dateTime" } } rows { quad { s_iri { prefix_id: 3 name_id: 1 } p_iri { prefix_id: 7 name_id: 66 } o_literal { lex: "2026-11-08T16:24:31.757Z" datatype: 3 } g_iri { prefix_id: 9 name_id: 9 } } } rows { name { value: "creator" } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 7 name_id: 67 } o_iri { prefix_id: 16 name_id: 53 } } } rows { prefix { id: 2 value: "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 7 name_id: 41 } o_iri { prefix_id: 2 name_id: 2 } } } rows { prefix { id: 14 value: "http://purl.org/nanopub/x/" } } rows { name { value: "hasNanopubType" } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 14 name_id: 68 } o_iri { prefix_id: 10 name_id: 14 } } } rows { name { value: "introduces" } } rows { prefix { id: 12 value: "https://w3id.org/delphi/resource/assessment/" } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 14 name_id: 69 } o_iri { prefix_id: 12 name_id: 12 } } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 11 name_id: 16 } o_literal { lex: "Claim test of aristotle-ha04-08: refutes, confidence 0.73" } } } rows { name { value: "domain" } } rows { prefix { value: "https://w3id.org/delphi/resource/domain/" } } rows { name { value: "aristotle-biology" } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 10 name_id: 70 } o_iri { prefix_id: 13 } } } rows { name { value: "sig" } } rows { name { value: "hasAlgorithm" } } rows { quad { s_iri { prefix_id: 9 } p_iri { prefix_id: 14 } o_literal { lex: "RSA" } } } rows { name { value: "hasPublicKey" } } rows { quad { p_iri { } o_literal { lex: "MIIBIjANBgkqhkiG9w0BAQEFAAOCAQ8AMIIBCgKCAQEAyFHtPB6p0mCjDozxlOY9CmO3nBm7Te3jFbXyLmM+G1tGe47Da0jYIbhkl9Oo1ZjxmCa3LCwlEqK8gj6hEIcL4ahW30JXh9HycfKVk1bugkzMEV15tJdTzAU3sGMFnbNsn43xY2LFLy45tApkRm5byEiM7oRRrooIdwoQKnP4Wzq/bfAoJ9qvW+MGkelyOTd1jbSt+KfmT7xKmDfWzAHddUlWwMX2QJOLxDaffOteTop6ZRgPiNmPJKA/S62Gac9XtSYT3oDkZ6/nr5cxxNLpOyxTf5FPISiCe11xYO/unYjY+mwnOfA8yhJIyx1l0O9I0vpOpn+E5TvyHJV+oSTrvwIDAQAB" } } } rows { name { value: "hasSignature" } } rows { quad { p_iri { } o_literal { lex: "paTkuThFFy6/zy9eN3iD/9SAZNdRqeqwcd18jnmUwmcnjxiK14CxP33MhMwzji7ZyLWSFNof0Bg/TFvZxMUJaVixZdiM0QWkHbpIxGtngrbfVXg1f/ETBiynqPBizdxtwy+7C51Wkw0yKKwuwJuMzzI+Ad1UAXHV6MOsqt8QzDdmO7WDCCPrueK9chNAQ92tpMZ8sjN0oVaT29ciTi7xtq0OzVhnscbBJK+IxLj8wdW3dPepCo/9vtcE6CC8gRUBn6WD8b1eK0ODXTjGxEvj6SR2yNHyq9pFM1BZB5gnsQ91KjUG1x2PjRzDsYsv1EjLQJnR6/QRkwx0V4+Ef6cpIw==" } } } rows { name { value: "hasSignatureTarget" } } rows { quad { p_iri { } o_iri { prefix_id: 3 name_id: 1 } } } rows { name { value: "signedBy" } } rows { quad { p_iri { prefix_id: 14 name_id: 77 } o_iri { prefix_id: 16 name_id: 53 } } }